Notes to the consolidated financial statements | Note 38

38. Nature and extent of risks arising from financial instruments
38.1 Risk management overview

The Group has exposure to the following risks from its use of financial instruments: credit risk; liquidity risk; foreign currency risk; interest rate risk and market price risk.

This note presents information about the Group’s exposure to each of the aforementioned risks, the Group’s objectives, policies and processes for measuring and managing risk, and the Group’s management of capital. IFRS 7 requires certain disclosures by class of instrument which the Group has determined would be the segments as disclosed in the segmental report.

The Group’s major financial risks are mitigated in the way that it operates firstly through diversification of industry and secondly through decentralisation. Bidvest is an international group with operations in South Africa, the United Kingdom, Namibia, and various other southern African countries. The Group also comprises a variety of businesses within the services, trading and distribution industries. As a result of this diversification in terms of industry, the Group is exposed to a range of financial risks, each managed in appropriate ways. However, the impact of any one particular financial risk within any of these industries, is not considered to be material to the Group.

The Group’s philosophy has always been to empower management through a decentralised structure thereby making them responsible for the management and performance of their operations, including managing the financial risks of the operation. The operational management report to divisional management who in turn report to the Group’s board of directors. The divisional management are also held responsible for managing financial risks of the operations within the divisions. Operational management’s remuneration is based on their operation’s performance and divisional management based on their division’s performance resulting in a decentralised and entrepreneurial environment.

Due to the diverse structure and decentralised management of the Group, the Group risk committee has implemented guidelines of acceptable practices and basic procedures to be followed by divisional and operational management. The information provided below for each financial risk has been collated for disclosure based on the manner in which the business is managed and what is believed to be useful information for shareholders.

The total process of risk management in the Bidvest Group, which includes the related system of control, is the responsibility of the board of directors. The Group risk committee has been constituted as a committee of the Group board of directors in the discharge of its duties and responsibilities in this regard. The Group risk committee has a charter and reports regularly to the board of directors on its activities.

The primary purposes of the Group risk committee are:
to establish and maintain a common understanding of the risk universe (framework), which needs to be addressed in order to meet Bidvest Corporate objectives;
to identify the risk profile and agree the risk appetite of the Group;
to satisfy the risk management reporting requirements;
to coordinate the Group’s risk management and assurance efforts;
to report to the board of directors on the risk management work undertaken and the extent of any action taken by management to address areas identified for improvement; and
to report to the board of directors on the Company’s process for monitoring compliance with laws and regulations.

The Group risk committee has documented a formal policy framework in order to achieve the following:
to place accountability on management for designing, implementing and monitoring the process of risk management;
to place responsibility on management for integrating the risk management process into the day-to-day activities and operations of the Group; and
to ensure that the risk strategy is communicated to all stakeholders so that it may be incorporated into the culture of the Group.

The Group has operations trading in the banking, short-term insurance and life assurance industries (Financial Services segment). These operations are exposed to financial risks which are unique to these industries and differ significantly to the remainder of the Group’s operations operating within the services, trading and distribution sectors. While the financial risks to which these particular operations are exposed could have a significant effect on the individual operations, they would not have a significant impact on the Group. For this reason, the information provided below mainly provides qualitative and quantitative information regarding the management and exposure to financial risks to which the trading operations of the Group are exposed based on what is believed to be useful to shareholders. Bidvest Bank Limited is a public company for which financial statements are prepared including detailed disclosure in accordance with the requirements of IFRS 7.

The Bidvest Group has, due to the diversity of its operations in nature and geography, determined that it would be better to develop an in-house strategy, as opposed to adopting a recognised strategy and forcing its operations to adapt to the constraints of the strategy selected. The Group has determined that utilising a common framework for the identification of risk would assist the divisions to reduce the implementation time and cost and would give some assurance that all inherent risks have been considered. The Group’s risk management policies are established to identify and analyse the risks faced by the Group, to set appropriate risk limits and controls, and to monitor risks and adherence to limits. Risk management policies and systems are reviewed regularly to reflect changes in market conditions and Group activities. The Group, through its training and management standards and procedures, aims to develop a disciplined and constructive control environment in which all employees understand their roles and responsibilities.

To assist the Group risk committee in discharging its responsibilities, it has:
assigned risk management responsibilities to divisional/operational risk committees; and
determined that each division should appoint risk/compliance officers on a divisional (operational) level as nominated by the divisional risk committees.

The role of the risk officer is to develop, communicate, coordinate and monitor the enterprise-wide risk management.

Through the divisional risk committees, each division has a forum for the discussion and identification of risks relevant to the particular division. Only risk matters that affect the Group as a whole are escalated to the Group risk committee. The minutes of the divisional risk committees are submitted to the Group risk committee.

Each division has its own audit committee, which subscribes to the same philosophies and practices as the Group audit committee. The divisional audit committees report to both the divisional board and the Group audit committee. The Group audit committee reviews the divisional audit committee reports. The divisional audit committees oversee how divisional management monitors compliance with the Group’s policies and guidelines in respect of the financial reporting process, the system of internal control, the management of financial risks, the audit process (both internal and external) and code of business conduct. The divisional audit committees are assisted in their oversight role by the Group’s internal audit department. Divisional internal audit undertakes both regular and ad hoc reviews of financial and operational risk management controls and procedures, the results of which are reported to the relevant divisional audit committee.

38.2 Credit risk

Credit risk is the risk of financial loss to the Group if a customer or counterparty to a financial instrument fails to meet its contractual obligations, and arises principally from the Group’s receivables from customers, banking advances, investments and guarantees.

The Group risk committee with the assistance of internal audit has implemented a “delegation of authority matrix” which provides guidelines by division, as to the level of authorisation required for various types of transactions.

Except as detailed below in respect of guarantees issued, the carrying amount of financial assets recorded in the financial statements, which is net of impairment losses, represents the Group’s maximum exposure to credit risk after taking into account the value of any collateral obtained. The carrying values, net of impairment allowances, amount to R7 277 million (2015: R19 007 million) for trade receivables (refer note 23), R1 698 million (2015: R1 288 million) for banking and other advances (refer note 20), and R2 870 million (2015: R2 551 million) for investments (refer note 19).

The impairment allowance account in respect of trade receivables and banking advances are used to record impairment losses unless the Group is satisfied that no recovery of the amount owing is possible; at that point, the amount which is considered irrecoverable is written off directly against the respective assets.

Impairments of investments classified as available-for-sale or held-for-trading are written off against the investment directly and an impairment allowance account is not utilised.

The Group has a general credit policy of only dealing with creditworthy counterparties and obtaining sufficient collateral, where appropriate, as a means of mitigating the risk of financial loss from defaults. In accordance with the decentralised structure, the operational management, under the guidance of the divisional management, are responsible for implementation of policies to meet the above objective. This includes credit policies under which new customers are analysed for creditworthiness before the operation’s standard payment and delivery terms and conditions are offered, determining whether collateral is required, and if so the type of collateral to be obtained, and setting of credit limits for individual customers based on their references and credit ratings. Certain operations in the Group have a policy of taking out credit insurance to cover a portion of their risk. Operational management are also held responsible for monitoring the operations’ credit exposure.

38.2.1 Trade receivables

Refer note 23 for further disclosure.

Trade receivables consist of a large number of customers, spread across diverse industries and geographical areas. Ongoing credit evaluation is performed by the operational management on the financial condition of the operation’s customers.

The Group does not have any significant credit risk exposure to any single counterparty or any group of counterparties having similar characteristics. It was noted that the Group’s largest exposure to a single customer group, across multiple geographies is R165 million (2015: R494 million). Management, in the various geographies, have assessed the recoverability of these amounts due in their geographies, and believe that the amounts due and not impaired are recoverable in full.

The total number of debtors per reporting division was obtained and the average turnover per trade debtor was calculated for each reporting division. Based on the average turnover per trade debtor in comparison to the Group’s total turnover for the year, there was no significant concentration of credit risk to any single trade debtor. The concentration of credit risk is therefore limited due to the customer base being large and independent.

Each operation establishes an impairment allowance that represents its estimate of incurred losses in respect of trade and other receivables. The main components of this allowance are a specific loss component that relates to individually significant exposures, and a collective loss component established for groups of similar assets in respect of losses that have been incurred but not yet identified.

As a result of the decentralised structure, operational management have the responsibility of determining the impairment allowances in respect of trade receivables. This is done under the oversight of the divisional audit committees, and ultimately the Group audit committee. The operations’ average credit period depend on the type of industry in which they operate as well as the creditworthiness of their customers. The majority of the customers are given credit terms ranging from cash on delivery to 60 days from statement. The largest impairment raised for a specific trade receivable was obtained for each reporting operation and calculated as a percentage of the Group’s total impairment allowance. It was determined that such percentage did not exceed 4,0% (2015: 2,0%) of the total allowance raised at year-end.

      2016 
R’000 
      2015 
R’000 
 
Movement in impairment allowance in respect of trade receivables                
Balance at July 1        633 232           514 318    
Allowances raised during the year        164 786           134 636    
   Bidvest South Africa                          
    Automotive        23 730           13 871    
    Commercial Products        14 568           3 496    
    Electrical        44 211           42 758    
    Financial Services        7 587           34    
    Freight        9 460           6 893    
    Office and Print        26 175           18 043    
    Services        18 788           30 683    
   Bidvest Namibia        18 256           18 387    
   Bidvest Corporate        2 011           471    
Bad debts written off during the year        (68 283)          (58 914)   
   Bidvest South Africa                          
    Automotive        (7 709)          (7 379)   
    Commercial Products        (12 713)          (2 093)   
    Electrical        (31 827)          (19 228)    
    Financial Services         –            (584)   
    Freight        (858)          (5 956)   
    Office and Print        (5 977)          (5 749)   
    Services        (6 766)          (13 090)   
   Bidvest Namibia        (2 072)           (4 300)   
   Bidvest Corporate        (361)          (535)   
Net acquisition of businesses and inter-class transfers        (747)          (2 825)   
   Bidvest South Africa                          
    Automotive         –            –    
    Commercial Products        5 652            –    
    Electrical         –            –    
    Financial Services         –            –    
    Freight        (9 945)          –    
    Office and Print        130           (1 969)     
    Services        (671)          (856)     
   Bidvest Namibia        4 087           –     
   Bidvest Corporate         –            –     
Allowances reversed during the year        (70 308)          (50 914)   
   Bidvest South Africa                          
    Automotive        (8 285)           (1 552)   
    Commercial Products        (2 504)          (2 328)   
    Electrical        (19 112)          (23 287)   
    Financial Services         –            12    
    Freight        (8 295)          64    
    Office and Print        (15 249)          (7 865)   
    Services        (3 672)          (4 880)   
   Bidvest Namibia        (12 979)          (11 030)   
   Bidvest Corporate        (212)          (48)   
Exchange rate adjustments        4 429           1 137    
Discontinued operations        (406 106)          95 794    
Balance at June 30        257 003           633 232    

Ageing of trade receivables at June 30

            2016                     2015        
      Gross trade
receivables
R’000
    Impairment 
allowance 
R’000 
    Net trade 
receivables 
R’000 
        Gross trade
receivables
R’000
    Impairment 
allowance 
R’000 
    Net trade
receivables
R’000
 
Not past due        5 553 590        (6 268)       5 547 322              5 287 437        (7 714)       5 279 723    
   Bidvest South Africa                                                                
     Automotive        327 471        (3 882)       323 589              298 213        (363)       297 850    
     Commercial Products        649 683        (146)       649 537              477 594        (396)       477 198    
     Electrical        511 722        (27)       511 695              600 584        –        600 584    
     Financial Services        146 943        –        146 943              60 167        –        60 167    
     Freight        1 459 706        –        1 459 706              1 571 404        (1 738)       1 569 666    
     Office and Print        937 684        (130)       937 554              848 963        (2 382)       846 581    
     Services        1 121 079        (580)       1 120 499              1 049 071        (2 835)       1 046 236    
   Bidvest Namibia        291 298        (40)       291 258              287 675        –        287 675    
   Bidvest Corporate        108 004        (1 463)       106 541              93 766        –        93 766    
Past due                                                                
0 – 30 days        1 026 895        (17 372)       1 009 523              1 155 260        (10 173)       1 145 087    
   Bidvest South Africa                                                                
     Automotive        91 854        (5 381)       86 473              83 663        (4 943)       78 720    
     Commercial Products        57 707        (251)       57 456              39 671        (67)       39 604    
     Electrical        206 611        (180)       206 431              119 681        –        119 681    
     Financial Services        75 962        (7 587)       68 375              4 863        –        4 863    
     Freight        73 922        (1 545)       72 377              124 974        (2 513)       122 461    
     Office and Print        155 067        (723)       154 344              160 990        (570)       160 420    
     Services        273 154        (883)       272 271              550 541        (2 079)       548 462    
   Bidvest Namibia        48 301        (772)       47 529              39 444        (1)       39 443    
   Bidvest Corporate        44 317        (50)       44 267              31 433        –        31 433    
31 – 180 days        672 517        (83 973)       588 544              586 214        (84 212)       502 002    
   Bidvest South Africa                                                                
     Automotive        96 297        (35 920)       60 377              11 769        (3 534)       8 235    
     Commercial Products        40 086        (7 960)       32 126              20 463        (3 171)       17 292    
     Electrical        134 938        (8 615)       126 323              175 527        (10 318)       165 209    
     Financial Services        50 461        –        50 461              3 968        –        3 968    
     Freight        59 038        (3 487)       55 551              60 397        (11 382)       49 015    
     Office and Print        64 817        (7 830)       56 987              72 181        (8 851)       63 330    
     Services        163 912        (15 380)       148 532              204 069        (43 398)       160 671    
   Bidvest Namibia        19 101        (3 575)       15 526              19 639        (2 486)       17 153    
   Bidvest Corporate        43 867        (1 206)       42 661              18 201        (1 072)       17 129    
181 + days        280 542        (149 390)       131 152              203 048        (125 027)       78 021    
   Bidvest South Africa                                                                
     Automotive        34 856        (30 540)       4 316              10 382        (8 417)       1 965    
     Commercial Products        6 578        (1 966)       4 612              8 233        (1 671)       6 562    
     Electrical        110 358        (29 489)       80 869              58 933        (34 719)       24 214    
     Financial Services        –        –        –              1 521        –        1 521    
     Freight        14 068        (9 370)       4 698              24 951        (7 499)       17 452    
     Office and Print        13 357        (12 255)       1 102              13 444        (6 093)       7 351    
     Services        78 452        (48 762)       29 690              40 013        (32 320)       7 693    
   Bidvest Namibia        18 233        (14 846)       3 387              16 508        (8 683)       7 825    
   Bidvest Corporate        4 640        (2 162)       2 478              29 063        (25 625)       3 438    
Discontinued operations        –        –        –              12 408 605        (406 106)       12 002 499    
Total        7 533 544        (257 003)       7 276 541              19 640 564        (633 232        19 007 332    

Collateral held on past due amounts

      2016         2015  
      Fair value of
collateral held
R’000
    Trade
receivables
net of
impairment
allowance
R’000
        Fair value of
collateral held
R’000
    Trade
receivables
net of
impairment
allowance
R’000
 
Personal surety     *     113 657         *     61 225  
   Bidvest South Africa                              
     Automotive           8 692               1 905  
     Commercial Products           2 004               515  
     Electrical           102 345               57 224  
     Freight           383                
     Office and Print           233               180  
     Discontinued operations                         1 401  
  Cover by credit insurance     326 206     326 206         383 422     386 447  
   Bidvest South Africa                              
     Automotive                 109     109  
     Commercial Products     16 403     16 403         15 958     15 958  
     Electrical     260 642     260 642         198 051     198 051  
     Freight     48 882     48 882         15 059     15 059  
   Bidvest Namibia     279     279         275     275  
   Discontinued operations                 153 970     156 995  
Pledge of assets     33 904     33 904         17 681     17 681  
   Bidvest South Africa                              
     Automotive     469     469         1 926     1 926  
     Commercial Products     787     787              
     Electrical     7 724     7 724         3 201     3 201  
     Office and Print     248     248         1 007     1 007  
     Services     24 676     24 676         11 547     11 547  
     Other     20 997     20 997         34 837     34 837  
   Bidvest South Africa                              
     Commercial Products     3 124     3 124         1 182     1 182  
     Freight     17 873     17 873         33 655     33 655  
Total     381 107     494 764         435 940     500 190  

* An accurate fair value cannot be attached to personal surety.

In certain instances the Group’s operations reserve the right to collect inventory sold when the outstanding debt is not settled by the customer. Where it is the business of the operation to finance assets, the assets are held as collateral in respect of the outstanding debt. The collateral detailed above is in addition to these aforementioned measures taken to reduce credit risk in respect of trade receivables.

38.2.2 Banking and other advances
Refer note 20 for further disclosure.

The impairment allowance account comprises a specific and portfolio impairment allowance. Specific impairments are raised for doubtful advances, including amounts in respect of interest not being serviced and after taking security values into account, and are deducted from advances where the outstanding balance exceeds the value of the security held. A portfolio impairment allowance based on historic experience is raised to cover doubtful advances, which may not be specifically identified at the statement of financial position date. The specific and portfolio impairments made during the year are charged to the income statement.

    2016 
R’000 
    2015 
R’000 
 
Movement in impairment allowance in respect of banking and other advances            
Financial Services            
Balance at July 1     5 477        9 921    
Allowance raised during the year     26 218        960    
Allowance utilised during the year      –         (455)   
Impairment written off against banking and other advances     (2 325)       (4 949)   
Balance at June 30     29 370        5 477    

Ageing of banking and other advances at June 30

            2016                     2015        
      Gross 
banking 
and other 
advances 
R’000 
    Impairment 
allowance 
R’000 
    Net 
banking 
and other 
advances 
R’000 
        Gross 
banking 
and other 
advances 
R’000 
    Impairment 
allowance 
R’000 
    Net 
banking 
and other 
advances 
R’000 
 
Financial Services                                          
Not past due        1 722 191        (26 235)       1 695 956              1 279 984        (1 136)       1 278 848    
Past due        5 441        (3 135)       2 306              13 047        (4 341)       8 706    
0 – 30 days              –                    96        (75)       21    
31 – 180 days        1 261        –        1 261              2 707        (614)       2 093    
181 + days        4 177        (3 135)       1 042              10 244        (3 652)       6 592    
Total        1 727 632        (29 370)       1 698 262              1 293 031        (5 477)       1 287 554    

Collateral held on past due amounts

      2016         2015  
      Fair value of
collateral held
R’000
    Banking
and other
advances net
of impairment
allowance
R’000
        Fair value of
collateral held
R’000
    Banking
and other
advances net
of impairment
allowance
R’000
 
Pledge of asset     2 306     2 306         8 706     8 706  
38.2.3

Investments

Refer note 19 for further disclosure.

The classes for investments are listed held-for-trading, unlisted held-for-trading, listed available-for-sale and unlisted available-for-sale, refer note 19 for the carrying amounts for each of these categories.

There were no impairment losses recognised in respect of investments (2015: Nil).

38.2.4 Guarantees

Over and above the guarantees issued to subsidiaries of the Group, the Group has provided guarantees for fixed amounts in respect of obligations of associates as disclosed in note 37.

The maximum exposure to credit risk in respect of guarantees at the reporting date was as follows:

    2016
R’000
    2015
R’000
 
Guarantees issued in respect of obligations of associates   166 000     166 000  
38.3 Liquidity risk

Liquidity risk is the risk that the Group will not be able to meet its financial obligations as they fall due. The Group’s approach to managing liquidity is to ensure, as far as possible, that it will always have sufficient liquidity to meet its liabilities when due, under both normal and stressed conditions, without incurring unacceptable losses or risking damage to the Group’s reputation.

The Group manages its borrowings centrally for each of the following countries and regions: South Africa, United Kingdom and Namibia. The divisions within each region are therefore not responsible for the management of liquidity risk but rather senior management for each of these regions are responsible for implementing procedures to manage the regional liquidity risk.

38.3.1 Contractual maturities of financial liabilities, including interest payments and excluding the impact of netting agreements

          Undiscounted contractual cash flows    
  Carrying
amount
R’000
    Total
R’000
6 months
or less
R’000
6 – 12
months
R’000
    1 – 2
years
R’000
2 – 5
years
R’000
More than
5 years
R’000
 
2016                        
Puttable non-controlling liabilities (refer note 31) 49 167     65 142     35 024 30 118  
Borrowings (refer note 29)                        
   Loans secured by mortgage bonds over fixed property 8 462     9 972 1 610 1 610     3 220 2 445 1 087  
   Loans secured by lien over certain property, plant and equipment in terms of financial leases and suspensive sale agreements 130 187     151 013 37 618 29 673     43 959 39 763  
   Unsecured loans 6 661 410     8 004 584 855 541 247 734     1 835 984 5 040 102 25 223  
   Floorplan creditors secured by pledge of inventories 976 356     976 356 976 356      
   Bank overdrafts 1 205 701     1 205 701 1 205 701      
  8 982 116     10 347 626 1 871 125 1 484 718     1 883 163 5 082 310 26 310  
Trade and other payables (refer note 34)                        
   Trade and other payables (excluding forward exchange contracts) 10 996 530     10 996 530 10 996 530      
  10 996 530     10 996 530 10 996 530      
Amounts owed to bank depositors (refer note 32)                        
   Call deposits 2 204 579     2 378 027 2 378 027      
   Fixed and notice deposits 1 484 582     1 535 634 1 079 244 456 390      
  3 689 161     3 913 661 3 457 271 456 390      
2015                        
Puttable non-controlling liabilities (refer note 31) 939 430     989 972     989 972  
Borrowings (refer note 29)                        
   Loans secured by mortgage bonds over fixed property 26 476     28 305 3 098 3 065     6 037 16 105  
   Loans secured by lien over certain property, plant and equipment in terms of financial leases and suspensive sale agreements 295 975     315 276 72 369 71 100     87 977 83 830  
   Unsecured loans 12 434 627     14 081 716 3 775 953 2 210 760     1 859 482 6 169 062 66 459  
   Vehicle lease creditors secured by a pledge of inventories                        
                       
Floorplan creditors secured by pledge of inventories 827 664     827 664 827 664      
Bank overdrafts 1 994 365     1 994 365 1 994 365      
  15 579 107     17 247 326 4 679 084 4 279 290     1 953 496 6 268 997 66 459  
Trade and other payables (refer note 34)                        
   Trade and other payables (excluding forward exchange contracts) 29 537 909     29 537 909 29 537 909      
  29 537 909     29 537 909 29 537 909      
Amounts owed to bank depositors (refer note 32)                        
   Call deposits 1 657 612     1 657 809 1 657 809      
   Fixed and notice deposits 996 249     1 025 766 774 061 251 705      
  2 653 861     2 683 575 2 431 870 251 705      

The expected maturity of financial liabilities is not expected to differ from the contractual maturities as disclosed above.

There were no defaults or breaches of any of the borrowing terms or conditions.

38.3.2 Trade and other payables by class
    2016
R’000
    2015
R’000
 
Trade payables            
  Bidvest South Africa            
     Automotive   625 512     482 058  
     Commercial Products   505 286     400 917  
     Electrical   692 585     658 829  
     Financial Services   171 878     799 808  
     Freight   2 417 511     2 526 465  
     Office and Print   1 165 113     888 773  
     Services   524 061     704 362  
Bidvest Namibia   270 987     368 457  
Bidvest Corporate   186 660     147 574  
Discontinued operations       14 396 569  
    6 559 593     21 373 812  

Refer note 34 for further disclosure.

38.3.3 Undrawn facilities

      2016
R’000
        2015
R’000
 
The Group has the following undrawn facilities at its disposal to further reduce liquidity risk:                  
Unsecured bank overdraft facility, reviewed annually and payable on 360 days notice     11 130 472         12 686 297  
   Utilised     1 205 701         1 994 365  
   Unutilised     9 924 771         10 691 932  
Unsecured loan facility with various maturity dates through to 2021 and which may be extended by mutual agreement     4 982 675         11 082 322  
   Utilised     3 736 410         8 166 034  
   Unutilised     1 246 265         2 916 288  
Secured loan facilities with various maturity dates through to 2022 and which may be extended by mutual agreement     3 436 524         2 950 629  
   Utilised     1 115 005         1 150 115  
   Unutilised     2 321 519         1 800 514  
Other banking facilities     1 943 738         3 130 867  
   Utilised     608         241 036  
   Unutilised     1 943 130         2 889 831  
Unsecured Domestic Medium Term Notes Programme     9 000 000         9 000 000  
   Utilised     2 925 000         4 268 593  
   Unutilised     6 075 000         4 731 407  
Total facilities     30 493 409         38 850 115  
   Utilised     8 982 724         15 820 143  
   Unutilised     21 510 685         23 029 972  
38.4 Market risk
Market risk is the risk that changes in market price, such as foreign exchange rates, interest rates and equity prices will affect the Group’s income or the value of its holdings of financial instruments. The objective of market risk management is to manage and control market risk exposures within acceptable parameters, while optimising the return on risk.
   
38.4.1 Foreign currency risk

The Group’s financial instruments are not significantly exposed to currency risk for the reasons provided below. A sensitivity analysis has therefore not been performed.

Borrowings are matched to the same foreign currency as the division raising the loan thereby limiting the divisions’ exposure to changes in a foreign currency which differs to their functional currency. Interest on borrowings is denominated in currencies that match the cash flows generated by the underlying divisions of the Group thereby providing an economic hedge for each class of borrowing.

Banking advances (refer note 20), amounts owed to bank depositors (refer note 32) and investments, with the exception of the Group’s investment in the Indian-based Mumbai International Airport Private Limited, (refer note 19) are all denominated in the same functional currency as the operation in which they are held, thus these financial instruments are not exposed to currency risk.

The Group incurs currency risk as a result of purchases and sales which are denominated in a currency other than the Group entities’ functional reporting currency. It is Group policy that Group entities hedge all trade receivables and trade payables denominated in a foreign currency which differs to its functional currency. At any point in time the entities also take out economic hedges over their estimated foreign currency exposure resulting from sales and purchases. The Group entities hedge their foreign currency risk exposure either by taking out forward exchange contracts (FECs) or alternatively by purchasing in advance the foreign currency which will be required to settle the trade payables. Most of the forward exchange contracts have maturities of less than one year after the balance sheet date. Where necessary, the forward exchange contracts are rolled over at maturity. It is the Group’s policy not to trade in derivative financial instruments for speculative purposes with the exception of Bidvest Bank Limited whose business is to trade in derivatives.

Changes in the fair value of forward exchange contracts that economically hedge monetary assets and liabilities in foreign currencies (in relation to the operations’ functional currency) and for which no hedge accounting is applied are recognised in the income statement. Both the changes in fair value of the forward exchange contracts and the foreign exchange gains and losses relating to the monetary items are recognised in operating profit (refer note 2).

The periods in which the cash flows associated with the forward exchange contracts are expected to occur are detailed below under the heading ‘Settlement’. The periods in which the cash flows are expected to impact the income statement are believed to be in the same time frame as when the actual cash flows occur.

          Contract value  
      Settlement   Foreign 
amount 
’000 
    Rand 
amount 
’000 
 
2016                  
In respect of forward exchange contracts relating to foreign liabilities as at June 30 2016                  
   Japanese yen         July 2016 to October 2016      (2 789 213)       (397 386)   
   US dollar         July 2016 to November 2016      (9 680)       (147 970)   
   Euro         July 2016 to October 2016      (2 139)       (37 107)   
   Sterling         July 2016 to October 2016      (166)       (3 727)   
   Australian dollar         July 2016      (35)       (400)   
  Other       July 2016 to August 2016      (1 117)       (2 260)   
                       (588 850)   
Other In respect of forward exchange contracts relating to foreign assets as at June 30 2016                    
   US dollar         July 2016 to November 2016      1 405         21 474     
In respect of forward exchange contracts relating to goods and services ordered not accounted for as at June 30 2016                             
   Japanese yen         July 2016      (4 803)       (690)   
   US dollar         July 2016 to January 2017      (24 702)       (370 125)   
   Euro         July 2016 to November 2016      (3 222)       (55 187)   
   Sterling         October 2016 to November 2016      (447)       (8 887)   
   Australian dollar         July 2016      (28)       (301)   
   Other         July 2016 to August 2016      (598)       (1 264)   
                        (436 454)   
2015                             
In respect of forward exchange contracts relating to foreign liabilities as at June 30 2015                             
   Japanese yen         July 2015 to November 2015      (2 434 570)       (246 804)   
   US dollar         July 2015 to October 2015      (25 313)       (300 680)   
   Euro         July 2015 to September 2015      (14 244)       (194 445)   
   Sterling         July 2015 to September 2015      (115)       (2 180)   
   Australian dollar         July 2015      (608)       (5 732)   
   Other       July 2015      (187)       (732)   
                        (750 573)   
Other In respect of forward exchange contracts relating to foreign assets as at June 30 2015                             
   US dollar         July 2015 to November 2015      1 336         16 615     
In respect of forward exchange contracts relating to goods and services ordered not accounted for as at June 30 2015                             
   Japanese yen         July 2015 to November 2015      (141 278)       (14 356)   
   US dollar         July 2015 to October 2015      (19 372)       (239 715)   
   Euro         July 2015 to December 2015      (881)       (11 199)   
   Sterling         August 2015 to September 2015      (489)       (9 393)   
   Australian dollar         July 2015      (1 314)       (12 266)   
   Other         July 2015 to September 2015      (350)       (1 289)   
                        (288 218)   

The total value of trade receivables and trade payables whose payment terms are fixed in a foreign currency other than its operational currency are R477 million (2015: R857 million) and R914 million (2015: R1 901 million), respectively.

38.4.2 Interest rate risk

The Group is exposed to interest rate risk as it borrows funds at both fixed and floating interest rates. This risk is managed by maintaining an appropriate mix between fixed and floating borrowings and by the use of interest rate swap contracts. The Group’s investments in listed bonds, accounted for as available-for-sale and held-for-trading financial assets and banking advances and liabilities are exposed to a risk of change in fair value due to movements in interest rates. Investments in equity securities accounted for as held-for-trading financial assets and trade receivables and payables are not exposed to interest rate risk.

At the reporting date the interest rate profile of the Group’s interest-bearing financial instruments was:

    2016 
R’000 
    2015 
R’000 
 
Fixed rate instruments            
   Financial assets            
     Available-for-sale listed bonds     229 184        92 964    
     Held-for-trading listed bonds     127 760        159 506    
     Banking and other advances     127 749        130 259    
     Derivative instruments in designated hedge accounting relationships     35 456        39 849    
   Financial liabilities                   
     Borrowings     (3 113 172)       (6 536 713)   
     Amounts owed to bank depositors     (778 024)       (327 444)   
     Derivative instruments in designated hedge accounting relationships     –        (1 863)   
Variable rate instruments                   
   Financial assets                   
     Cash and cash equivalents     3 911 927        7 812 877    
     Banking and other advances     1 570 513        1 162 774    
   Financial liabilities                   
     Borrowings     (4 663 243)       (7 048 029)   
     Puttable non-controlling interest liabilities     (49 167)       (939 430)   
     Amounts owed to bank depositors     (2 911 137)       (2 326 417)   
     Overdrafts     (1 205 701)       (1 994 365)   

 The Group’s exposure to interest rates on financial assets and liabilities are detailed in the various notes within the financial statements.

The variable rates are influenced by movements in the prime borrowing rates.

Sensitivity analysis
The effect of a change in interest rate on the fair value of the listed bonds accounted for as held-for-trading and available-for-sale is not believed to have a significant effect on the Group’s profit for the year and equity.

It is estimated that a 0,5% (2015: 0,5%) increase in interest rates would decrease profit after tax by R22 million (2015: R20 million). This sensitivity analysis has been prepared using the average borrowings for the financial year as the actual borrowings at June 30 are not representative of the borrowings during the year. This analysis assumes that all other variables, in particular foreign currency rates, remain constant. The analyses are performed on the same basis as 2015. A decrease in interest rates would have an equal and opposite effect on profit after taxation.

Interest rate swap contracts
The Group has entered into interest rate swap contracts, in order to fix the interest rates on variable rate corporate bonds and loans as summarised below.

Bonds – The variable three-month JIBAR interest rate plus a spread specific to each bond has been fixed using fixed for floating interest rate swaps at rates set out below. The swap contracts match the duration and expiry dates of the bonds. The difference between the fixed and floating interest rates are settled on a quarterly basis simultaneously with the payment of interest to bondholders. The interest rate swap contracts have enabled the Group to mitigate the risk of fluctuating interest rates on the fair value of the bonds issued. The interest rate swaps have been designated as hedging instruments and accounted for as a cash flow hedge. The fair value of the bond linked interest rate swaps at the reporting date, is determined by discounting the future cash flows using the interest rate curves at the reporting date and the credit risk inherent in the contract, resulting in a fair value asset of R35 million (2015: R40 million).

Hedged items – five-year bonds/stock code BID05   BID04  
Principal bond and swap notional value – R’000 260 000   1 425 000  
Bond issue date, swap start date June 30 2014   November 23 2012  
Bond redemption date, swap termination date June 30 2019   November 23 2017  
Spread (bps) above three-month JIBAR 125   130  
Fixed swap rate, including spread 8,75%   7,15%  
Interest settlement periods Quarterly   Quarterly  
38.4.3 Market price risk
Equity price risk arises from investments classified as held-for-trading and available-for-sale (refer note 19). Available-for-sale financial assets include listed bonds held by the Group’s wholly owned subsidiary Bidvest Bank Limited. Held-for-trading investments comprise a listed share portfolio whose performance is monitored closely by senior management and the Group actively trades in these shares. The Group’s subsidiaries Bidvest Insurance Limited and Bidvest Life Limited hold investment portfolios with a fair value of R496 million (2015: R645 million) and R93 million (2015: R306 million), respectively, for the purpose of being utilised to cover liabilities arising from insurance contracts. These portfolios comprise domestic and international equity investments and money market funds. Unlisted investments comprise unlisted shares and loans which are classified as held-for-trading and available-for-sale, and are valued at fair value using a price earnings (PE) model.
38.5 Fair values

The carrying amounts of all financial assets and liabilities approximate their fair values, with the exception of borrowings which have been accounted for at amortised cost. The fair value of borrowings, together with the carrying amounts shown in the statement of financial position, classified by class (being geographical location), are as follows:

      2016       2015  
      Carrying
amount
R’000
    Fair value
R’000
      Carrying
amount
R’000
    Fair value
R’000
 
Borrowings (refer note 29)                            
   Southern Africa     8 729 298     8 712 155       10 183 219     10 173 879  
      Loans secured by mortgage bonds over fixed property     3 765     3 765            
      Loans secured by lien over certain property, plant and equipment in terms of financial leases and suspensive sale agreements     44 663     45 272       14 503     15 345  
      Unsecured loans     6 661 410     6 643 658       7 383 614     7 373 432  
      Floor plan creditors secured by pledge of inventories     976 356     976 356       827 664     827 664  
      Bank overdrafts     1 043 104     1 043 104       1 957 438     1 957 438  
United Kingdom     252 818     252 818       164 881     164 881  
      Loans secured by mortgage bonds over fixed property     4 697     4 697       5 104     5 104  
      Loans secured by lien over certain property, plant and equipment in terms of financial leases and suspensive sale agreements     85 524     85 524       122 850     122 850  
      Unsecured loans                    
      Bank overdrafts     162 597     162 597       36 927     36 927  
Discontinued operations               5 231 007     5 230 701  
      8 982 116     8 964 973       15 579 107     15 569 461  
Unrecognised gain     17 143             9 646        

The methods used to estimate the fair values of financial instruments are discussed in note 42.

The interest rates used to discount cash flows, in order to determine fair values, are based on market related rates at June 30 2016 plus an adequate constant credit spread, and range from 1,0% to 10,5% (2015: 1,0% to 12,5%).


Notes to the consolidated financial statements | Note 38